Our pre-match read
FiorentinavsAtalanta
Win Probability
41%26%33%
Home winDrawAway win

There was a moment, around the 61st minute, when Fiorentina looked like they'd turned the corner. Up 2-1 at home, João Mário had just finished off a move that Alieu Njie started, and the Franchi had a pulse again. Then Nicola Zalewski scored thirteen minutes later, and the night ended the way the season has for both clubs — without a winner.

Our pre-match read leaned toward Fiorentina at 41%, reasonable given Atalanta's recent form. Neither side made that call look wrong exactly; they just kept canceling each other out.

The First Half: Atalanta Draw First Blood

For most of the opening 45, this was a scrappy, cautious affair. Eljif Elmas picked up a yellow in the 12th minute, Fiorentina's Viery followed in the 30th, and neither team was doing much to separate itself. Then, right before the break, Zalewski found De Ketelaere and the Belgian finished to give Atalanta the lead heading into the tunnel. A gut-punch goal at the worst possible time for the home side.

Fiorentina had 26 shots on the night to Atalanta's 10 — but only four of those 26 were on target. That number tells the story of a team that dominated territory without ever really threatening. Eight corners, 50 percent of the ball, and yet they needed a header from a patojo to get back into it.

The Second Half: Back and Forth, Then Nothing

Njie leveled in the 53rd minute, nodding home a cross from Álex Jiménez. It was the kind of goal that shifts momentum — direct, purposeful, a reminder that Fiorentina had the bodies in the box if they could get the ball there. Mateo Pellegrino was booked almost immediately after, but the Viola were buzzing.

Eight minutes later, João Mário made it 2-1. Njie, who'd just scored himself, turned provider, and the goal felt decisive. The Franchi believed it. El chispudo de Njie, making things happen in both directions in the span of a quarter-hour.

But Atalanta didn't fold. In the 74th minute, De Ketelaere returned the favor to Zalewski — same combination, reversed — and the Pole finished to make it 2-2. Cabal, that was the moment Fiorentina's night fell apart. Wilfried Gnonto was booked a minute later, probably a sign of the frustration bubbling over on the home bench. Atalanta's Relja Obric added his name to the card column in the 83rd, but neither side found a third.

Fiorentina's form coming in read DLLLD. They won't feel great about dropping points at home, especially having led. Atalanta's DDLLW suggests a team still finding its footing too — two wins in five isn't the profile of a side ready to go on a run. The question now is whether either club has the consistency to string results together, or whether nights like this — competitive, entertaining, ultimately empty — are just where they are right now.

Follow live scores and results across every major competition on the FutbolToday homepage, and find more analysis in our guides.